Illinois had broken up with me days earlier and I was finally going to get to really talk to JE about it. Walking home from the subway after work I eagerly dialed her number and we made plans to meet tonight at the bar. I needed her to be my mirror and reflect me back to myself and remind me of who I am and what I want; I am so lost I cannot see myself. I trust her advice will be well thought out and honest. Her voice will be a balm and a heating pad soothing my injured heart, reducing the swelling, enabling it to beat normally again. I rush home, change and rush to the bar to meet her and we drink wine.
Then I switch to Bass.
We talk about me moving to my new place and not staying in the apartment Illinois and I were living in together.
I need her so badly. I need her to be my friend and my comfort and my rock and my cushion and listen to me and calm me and I trust her advice and her wisdom but she doesn't ask me how I am. She steers the conversation to other topics. I can't keep up. She makes me feel greedy in wanting needing so badly to talk about myself. But I am going through a major life upheaval. It is a lot more than a regular stupid break-up. Does anyone understand that. No one seems to. She doesn't ask me how I am.
Then Illinois comes into the bar.
I go to the bathroom. I come back and they are sitting together.
JE walks away and leaves us alone. He asks me to go home to Illinois with him for Thanksgiving. Is he crazy? Of course I still have my ticket. We were supposed to get married in Illinois the Saturday after Thanksgiving. He told me two weeks ago that he didn't want anything that serious with me. Yet he wants me to go away with him to stay with his family whom I love and who love me for what was supposed to be our wedding. I tell him that I will have too much fun there. That I have been looking forward to it for so long that I can't bear the thought of us having such a great time and coming home to separate houses. And to this horrible situation we are now stuck in. Or at least I am stuck in.
Incredulation.
Am I crazy or is he crazy. I am not completely sure.
JE returns.
Apparently they have discussed this. She thinks it is a fabulous idea and encourages me to go.
Whose friend is she? Doesn't she see that I am broken beyond repair? That my heart is strewn on the floor of the bar in a thousand million pieces and I am barely holding it together enough to sit there and drink my Bass? Doesn't she see that I need her to listen to how I feel to try to understand me for a second? She has become a stranger. All of a sudden one of my best friends in the world who I have loved and trusted and cried with and laughed with and taken walks with and taken runs with and gotten drunk with and studied with and defended and who has defended me and who I have been faithfully loyal to and relied upon and needed so badly is a stranger. I am so alone. I am with someone I have always felt safe with at my ugliest moments and now she is a stranger. And I need her so badly. I have never needed a friend so badly before. And she is with me yet she has somehow become loyal to him.
She leaves Illinois and I alone again.
This time she actually leaves the bar.
I keep waiting for her to return.
She doesn't come back because she has gone home to her new apartment with her new boyfriend and her perfect relationship. They were moving in together last week as I was moving out. I tell Illinois that I cannot go to Illinois with him for Thanksgiving and I go home. I never hear from JE again. I call her. I text message her. I call her. I e-mail her. I call her. She refuses to be my friend. Just like that.
We met in law school. I noticed her during our first year where fate placed placed us in the same section, section B. I noticed her for the same reasons that everyone else noticed her. She was loud. She was opinionated. She was smart. She asked questions the professors didn't always know the answers to. Rumors swarmed about her. Supposedly she didn't buy the textbooks because she didn't need to read to keep her 4.0 average. Supposedly she took great notes and remembered everything that was said in class. Supposedly she smoked pot every single day. I admired her because she was so unlike me. She was fearless and was never afraid to ask a question or talk to anyone, even a professor, even the dean. She could be placed in any situation with any group of people and always land on her feet.
Flashforward to our second year in law school. I am at North Moore Bar with my new boyfriend, Staten Island, who is a third year law student. No one from my year is there. I don't know any of the third year students. My boyfriend is the only person there that I know. He introduces me around and then leaves me at a table with his friend GM. I have nothing to say to GM. GM interviews me to determine whether I am worthy of dating his friend or being in their presence or at their bar. I squirm. GM is taking his role as Staten Island's protector a little too seriously. JE enters the bar. She makes a beeline for GM and I. Thank God. As intimidated as I am by JE, three is better than one on one. I eventually extricate myself and leave them alone. The night plays itself out. Staten Island spends most of the night with his friends and I spend most of the night trying to foster conversation with people I don't know and don't want to meet. I escape to an empty stool at the bar and take a break from the small talk. Suddenly JE hops onto the empty stool to my right with tears brimming in her eyes. She tells me her boyfriend is ignoring her. I didn't know she had a boyfriend. She confesses that GM is her boyfriend and immediately a bond forms between us. What a lucky coincidence. Unlike me she is unafraid to express her hurt feelings and outrage at how GM is ignoring her. Unlike me she knows she deserves more than the scraps we were both being given that night. We do a shot of tequila together. In minutes we are laughing at the boys that brought us together and the catch 22 we are both in; we love them but they don't treat us well. She's making fun of GM now and how he calls himself the 'mayor' of his class and how he tells her it's his obligation to mingle. Staten Island and I leave the bar and he spends the night with me for the first time. JE and GM stay outside the bar until after 2:00am arguing until she tearfully goes home alone. JE and I become friends that night. Just like that.
On my 24th birthday Staten Island breaks up with me. When I ask him why he couldn't have waited until after my birthday he sneers, "You'll have other birthdays." I tell JE this as we sit outside and smoke cigarettes and I cry on a bench in Tribeca across the street from the North Moore Bar. She laughs. His cruelty is so outrageous it's funny. I laugh too. Her relationship with GM is also in trouble. What's wrong with these guys we wonder. What's wrong with us for loving them. We get drunk and scour the East Village peaking our heads into their haunts and sometimes doing a shot or having a drink reminiscing about nights spent there with them and wondering what they are doing at that exact minute. Are they at the bar we just left; should we stay and play a song on the jukebox or smoke another cigarette here; if we stay long enough might they come in. Sometimes we actually find them. The best nights it is just us laughing and crying into our beers. On one of those nights she supports my decision to play, "You Sexy Thing," by Hot Chocolate on the juke box and leave it on Staten Island's voicemail. On another of those nights, I support her decision to get GM's number from an old phone bill she just happened to have in her purse and call him to say we were at the bar across the street from his house what a coincidence he should come meet us. Meanwhile we were at a 24-hour diner across the street from his apartment.
Post law school our friendship survived its ebbs and flows. We weren't in constant contact when she spent a year living in California. As soon as we reunited it was as if no time had passed. What a funny coincidence when we reconnected that we were both dating boys from Illinois who wanted us to move there with them. She broke up with hers and moved back to New York. Mine decided to stay in New York with me. I got laid off days after Illinois and I signed our lease together. JE got me contract work at her law firm. We worked on some cases together and suddenly it was like law school all over again and we were seeing each other every day and once again in constant contact. I told her when I heard that GM was engaged so she would have time to prepare an official comment when she inevitably heard it from the law school crowd. I invited her to a party with Illinois and I and our friends to cheer her up, and she hit it off with his friend SC. Our friendship hit its peak where we lived on the same street and worked at the same law firm and dated friends. On a typical day we had a few conversations running at once over email and would meet for lunch and cover another topic entirely and would then meet up for drinks after work with or without our boyfriends and reminisce about the GM and Staten Island days and how crazy we were and how thank goodness for them because they brought us together. She was my soul. She was my heart. When Illinois and I announced we were having a baby she cried louder than anyone. She was so excited for me.
Illinois called me out of the blue the other day and told me that JE and SC are getting married in a few weeks and they want him to speak at their wedding because if not for him, they never would have met. It's as if I never existed at all. She is perpetratrating a revisionist history of her life that doesn't include me. The lawyer in me feels like she is making an official record of my non-existence. Meanwhile I can't imagine the past seven years without her. She is an integral part of my life story. If I left her out, the story wouldn't be complete. If I left her out, I wouldn't be me.
Maybe surviving this without her by my side is something I should be proud of. Her abandonment of me forced me to be strong on my own. Maybe had she been there to put her healing balm on the bloody mess that was my heart I would never have learned the lessons I learned. Maybe she believed my bad luck would taint her hard earned happily ever after story. Maybe she felt that it had been me who had more luck in love until Illinois and she wanted some for herself. I don't know. Despite my overtures, she has never told me why she couldn't be there for me, why she chose that time not to be my friend anymore. Until then, her place in my heart remains vacant. She is irreplaceable. There is a part of me that will always remain dormant because it is only awakened by her.
Or maybe our friendship just ran its course. I met her when she was crying over a guy and she left me when I was crying over one. Full circle. Better to get off the Ferris wheel when you're on top.